Birthdays | Ruther's Sweetie Pie

What We Offer...

Drop Cookies

Monster Cookies
Huge melt in your mouth peanut butter and oatmeal cookie with chocolate chips and M&M's $15.00/doz

Chocolate Chip Cookie
Crisp around the edges with a soft center with milk chocolate chips $15.00/doz

Peanut Butter Cookies
Perfectly sweet and buttery rich, sure to satisfy the peanut butter craving. $15.00/doz

Sugar Cookies
Perfectly crisp with melt in your mouth greatness! $15.00/doz

Squash Cookies with Maple Frosting
Soft squash cookie that gives you the pumpkin flavor, with a perfect maple frosting $15.00/doz

Oatmeal Raisin Cookies
Crisp edges with a super soft center perfectly spiced to give you a flavorful cookie. $15.00/doz

Craisin White Chocolate
Sweet craisin flavor perfectly matched with white chocolate. $15.00/doz

Sugar Cookie Cutouts
Available in many shapes, simple frosting. Also, can order as a kit to decorate your own! $25.00/doz

Stuffed Cookies

Stuffed cookies are sold by 6 of 1 single flavor for $15.00

Apple Pie Snickerdoodles

Carmel filled Chocolate Chip Cookie

Cookies and Cream stuffed cookie

S'more Stuffed Cookie

Funfetti Stuffed Cookie

Strawberry Cheesecake Stuffed Cookie

Nutella Stuffed Cookie

Brownie Stuffed Chocolate Chip Cookie

Reese's Stuffed Peanut butter Cookie

Rolo Stuffed Cookie

Jelly Stuffed Peanut butter Cookie

Peanut butter Stuffed Chocolate Cookie

Snickers Stuffed Peanut butter Cookie

French Macarons

Minimum of 1 dozen flavor per order.

$20-$30 per dozen

Vanilla

Chocolate

Salted Carmel

Snickers

Cookies and Cream

Lemon

Strawberry

Carmel

Red Velvet

Mint

Pistachio

Tiramisu

Chocolate Peanut butter

Chocolate Cherry

Pumpkin Spice

S'mores

Classic Cupcakes

VANILLA WITH VANILLA BUTTERCREAM

Fluffy vanilla cake topped with light, creamy buttercream icing $20.00/doz

VANILLA WITH CHOCOLATE BUTTERCREAM

Fluffy vanilla cake topped with rich chocolate buttercream $20.00/doz

CHOCOLATE WITH CHOCOLATE BUTTERCREAM Fluffy chocolate cake topped with rich chocolate buttercream, a customer favorite! $20.00/doz

CHOCOLATE WITH VANILLA BUTTERCREAM

Fluffy chocolate cake topped with light vanilla buttercream icing. $20.00/doz

MARBLE WITH CHOCOLATE FROSTING

Fluffy chocolate and vanilla cake topped with rich chocolate buttercream. $20.00/doz

MARBLE WITH VANILLA FROSING
Fluffy chocolate and vanilla cake topped with light, creamy buttercream icing $20.00/doz

Candy Cupcakes

REESE'S CUPCAKE
Moist chocolate cupcake with peanut butter ﬁlling. Topped with a light peanut butter frosting $24.00/doz

SNICKER'S CUPCAKE
Moist Chocolate cupcake with caramel and peanut in the center, topped with caramel frosting. $24.00/doz

M&M CUPCAKE
Moist ﬂuffy vanilla cupcake with M&M's, topped with peanut butter frosting $24.00/doz

S'MORE'S CUPCAKE
Graham cracker crust ﬁlled with rich chocolate cupcake topped with toasted marshmallow
frosting. $24.00/doz

More Cupcakes

CARROT CAKE WITH CREAM CHEESE FROSTING

Deeply moist carrot cake with toasted pecans, topped with cream cheese frosting. $24.00/doz

GERMAN CHOCOLATE
Rich chocolate cupcake with an excellent coconut pecan frosting. $24.00/doz

SQUASH CUPCAKE WITH MAPLE FROSTING

Light moist ﬂavorful squash cupcake with a light maple frosting. $24.00/doz

SALTED CARAMEL CUPCAKE
The Ultimate Caramel cupcake with delicious salted caramel in the center and some more caramel sauce swirled into the frosting. $24.00/doz

LEMON RASPBERRY CUPCAKE
Light ﬂuffy lemon cake with a raspberry buttercream frosting. $24.00/doz

LEMON BLUEBERRY CUPCAKE
Blueberry cake topped with light lemon buttercream frosting $24.00/doz

BUTTER PECAN CUPCAKE
Toasted butter pecan cupcake with a browned butter frosting $24.00/doz

BLACK FOREST CUPCAKE
Light chocolate cupcake with cherry filling and a whipped buttercream frosting $24.00/doz

Pie

Hand-rolled buttery pastry crust, crimped to flaky perfection with homemade fillings.

Mini Pie Bites.......$10-$15 per dozen

Whole Pies (9” - serves 6-8).....$20-$25 each

Flavors: Blueberry ● Cherry ● Triple Berry ●Strawberry-Rhubarb ● Apple ● Salted Carmel Apple ● Strawberry ● Raspberry ● Pecan

Bread

Cinnamon Swirl Bread $9.00
Light airy white bread, with a cinnamon swirl throughout the loaf.

Banana Bread $7.00
Super moist flavorful bread available with or without walnuts

Zucchini Bread $7.00
Super moist flavorful bread available with or without walnuts

Star Bread $25.00
Large 12" round twisted and swirled with your favorite flavors!
Available in strawberry/rhubarb, cherry/rhubarb, blueberry, raspberry, and strawberry

Carmel Rolls $24.00
12 per order, with or without pecans

Cinnamon Rolls $24.00
12 per order

Scones

$15.00 for 6 Large Scones of a single flavor

Large scone with crunchy exterior with a super moist melt in your mouth center.

Flavors: Maple Bacon ● Raspberry White Chocolate ● Triple Berry White Chocolate ●Strawberry-Rhubarb ● Lemon Blueberry ● Carmel Apple ● Peach Almond

What We Offer...

Custom Order Inquiry

Subscribe to My Newsletter